“My Book Is Distributed to Bookstores” Does Not Mean “My Book Will Be Stocked in Bookstores”
I recently sent a note to all of my authors explaining why I keep our print books nonreturnable through IngramSpark by default.
The note was prompted by something I have heard more than once: an author approaches a bookstore about carrying their book and is told the store will not stock it because the title is nonreturnable.
That can be confusing.
After all, the book has global distribution. It is available to bookstores through Ingram. So why wouldn’t a bookstore simply order it?
Because distribution and bookstore placement are not the same thing.
I think authors deserve to understand the difference before making a financial decision simply because seeing their book on a bookstore shelf feels like the next obvious step.
What Bookstore Distribution Actually Means
When I say one of our books has distribution through Ingram, I mean the book is available through an established wholesale distribution system that bookstores, retailers, libraries, and other organizations use to source books.
That matters. It gives a bookseller a familiar channel through which the book can be ordered.
But distribution is access.
It is not placement.
It does not mean a bookstore has agreed to carry the book, purchased inventory, placed it on a table, or put copies on a shelf.
Those decisions belong to the bookseller.
This distinction may sound obvious once it is explained, but I think the language of publishing can make it very easy for authors to hear “bookstore distribution” and imagine “my book will be in bookstores.”
Those are two very different things.
Why Bookstores Care About Returnable Status
A bookstore is taking a financial risk when it orders inventory.
If the store buys ten copies of a book and only sells three, it does not want to be permanently stuck with the other seven.
The traditional book trade developed around returns in part to shift some of that inventory risk away from the bookseller.
That is why many bookstores prefer, and some require, books to be returnable before they will consider stocking them.
From the bookstore’s perspective, that makes perfect sense.
But the financial risk does not disappear.
It moves somewhere else.
When a Book Is Returnable, the Publisher Takes On the Risk
Through IngramSpark, a publisher that makes a title returnable agrees to accept the financial consequences if a bookseller sends unsold copies back.
This is the part I want my authors to understand clearly.
IngramSpark does not simply take back the book and reverse whatever small amount the publisher or author originally earned.
The publisher is charged the current wholesale cost of the returned book. Depending on the return option selected, additional shipping and handling charges can also apply.
IngramSpark gives a useful example using a book with a $20 list price and a 55 percent wholesale discount. The wholesale price is $9.
If that book is returned under the Return-Destroy option, the publisher is charged $9 for each returned copy even though the physical book is destroyed.
If Return-Deliver is selected for delivery to a U.S. address, Ingram currently adds a $3 per-copy shipping and handling charge.
That means 100 returned copies could create $900 in charges under Return-Destroy or $1,200 under Return-Deliver to a U.S. address.
Those charges can exceed the compensation generated by the original sales because printing costs were already deducted when the books were first sold.
In other words, returns can result in an invoice. They are not simply a reduction in royalties.
It Is Not a Switch I Can Turn On for One Bookstore
One of my authors asked me a very reasonable question after receiving my note.
Could we make the book returnable for one particular bookstore and leave it nonreturnable everywhere else?
No.
The return setting is part of the title’s distribution terms. Changing it makes the returnable status available through Ingram’s distribution network. It is not a bookstore-by-bookstore setting inside the IngramSpark account.
There is another important consideration.
If a title is changed from returnable back to nonreturnable, booksellers do not immediately lose the ability to return it. IngramSpark states that booksellers continue to have return rights for 180 days after notice of the change is provided to distribution partners.
So this is not something I view as a harmless switch we can flip on for an event and simply turn off again the next day.
Returnable Can Help. It Does Not Guarantee Bookstore Placement.
Making a book returnable may make a bookstore more willing to stock it.
That is different from guaranteeing that the bookstore will.
A bookseller still has to decide whether the book is right for its customers, whether it has room for it, whether the pricing and wholesale terms work, and whether the store believes copies are likely to sell.
This is why I do not think authors should accept the financial exposure of returns based on the assumption that returnable status automatically puts a book on shelves.
It removes one potential objection.
The bookseller still makes the decision.
I Love Bookstores. I Also Want Authors to Understand the Economics.
I understand the emotional appeal of bookstore placement.
I am a writer and publisher. I love bookstores.
There is something wonderful about walking into a bookstore and seeing a book you created sitting on a shelf.
I want my authors to have those moments.
But I also want them to understand what they may be agreeing to financially in order to pursue them.
Bookstore placement can offer visibility, credibility, community connection, event opportunities, and the simple pleasure of having your work physically present in a place devoted to books.
Those things have value.
But depending on the book and the circumstances, I may view bookstore placement more as a marketing investment than as the most profitable way for an author to sell books.
That is not a criticism of bookstores. Bookstores have rent, staff, inventory, and all the other costs of running a business. They need a margin and they need to manage their own risk.
The author simply needs to understand their side of the equation too.
Direct-to-Reader Sales Are a Different Economic Model
When an author sells a copy directly to a reader, there are fewer parties sharing the economics of that sale.
That can make direct sales much more attractive financially.
But I would not tell every author that direct sales should therefore become their entire strategy.
That would be replacing one formula with another.
For one book, bookstore placement may be incredibly important. For another, events, speaking, professional communities, schools, libraries, organizations, or direct relationships with readers may matter more.
The right decision depends on the author, the book, and what the author hopes the book will accomplish.
Why I Keep Our Books Nonreturnable by Default
My default is nonreturnable because I do not want to expose an author to potentially substantial return charges without their understanding and agreement.
That does not mean I am opposed to making a book returnable.
Going forward, if one of my authors decides bookstore stocking is an important part of their strategy and wants the book made returnable, we can have that conversation.
I will explain the potential costs, the author can consider the opportunity and the risk, and they can make an informed decision.
What I do not want is for an author to promise a bookstore that the book will be returnable without realizing what that promise can mean financially.
The Question Is Not Simply, “Can I Get My Book Into Bookstores?”
I think a better question is: What role do I want bookstores to play in the life of this particular book?
Maybe bookstore placement is deeply important to you.
Maybe there is a local independent bookstore that is a natural home for the work.
Maybe the book connects beautifully with events, readings, community conversations, or a particular geographic audience.
Maybe the visibility is worth treating as part of your marketing budget.
Or maybe your readers are more likely to find you somewhere else.
There is no single right answer. But there should be an informed one.
Distribution gives your book a pathway into the bookselling ecosystem.
It does not promise shelf space.
Returnable status may open more bookstore doors, but it also transfers real financial risk to the publisher and author.
Understanding that distinction lets you make the decision based on your book and your goals, rather than on what you thought the word distribution meant.
Have Questions About Distribution or the Best Path for Your Book?
I offer complimentary consultations for writers who want thoughtful guidance about publishing, distribution, and bringing their work into the world.
We can start with your book, your goals, and what you actually want publishing to accomplish for you.
Source note: IngramSpark policies and examples referenced in this article were verified against IngramSpark’s current guidance on book returns, wholesale terms, and changing return status. Understanding Book Returns with IngramSpark and Updating Pricing, Returns, and Discounts Weekly in IngramSpark.
Comments